Kaleidoscope home
helploginprintemail   log in  
  Search  

The Mediated Mind - Rethinking Representation

Symposium at the London Knowledge Lab
Friday, May 27th and Saturday, May 28th 2005

Background readings...

The Symposium is now over. We will keep the information for your reference.
The Philosophy of Technology-Enhanced Learning Special Interest Group Symposium

Do educational technologies demand a re-thinking of representation? The emergence of the Internet and other new technologies prioritises a range of important questions including issues of generic images, abstract reason, representations as tools, epistemic action, mediation and pictorial communication. Such philosophical questions are germane to our understanding of education and learning in the new millennium, and create an agenda for philosophy which this Symposium aims to facilitate. Some relevant thinkers include Wittgenstein, Sellars, Brandom, McDowell, the Toronto School, Derrida, Stiegler, Dewey, Vygotsky, Hutchins (distributed cognition), and Rogers and Scaife (external cognition) and many others. One aim of the Symposium will be to identify a set of primary questions in the philosophy of educational technology and to map out the territory in which these questions are currently considered.

Friday 27th May

1315
Lunch
1400

Introduction to the Symposium
Dr Jan Derry, London Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education
1405

Keynote - The Networked Mind Professor Kristóf Nyíri, Institute for Philosophical Research of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences
1445

Is my Mobile part of my Mind?
Dr John Preston, Philosophy Department, University of Reading
1525Tea
1545



1545


1615


1645



1715

1730


1800

Short contribution sessions (ten minute concise inputs followed by twenty minutes of discussion) Chair: Dr David Guile, Institute of Education, University of London

Professor Mike Sharples, Centre for Educational Technology and Distance Learning, University of Birmingham, Developing a Theory of Mobile Learning

Dr Jan Derry, The London Knowledge Lab, Epistemology and Conceptual Resources for the Development of Learning Technologies

Professor Bruno Bachimont, Université de Technologie de Compiègne
Remediating the Mind: intellectual technologies and knowledge reconfigurations

Break

Dr Russell Beale, School of Computer Science, University of Birmingham, Representing the Future

Dr Don Peterson, The London Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education
The Filtering Problem
1930
Symposium Dinner


Saturday 28th May

0930Thematic group discussions (see briefing note sheet)
1030 -
1130
Keynote - Alternative Conceptions of Representation in Contemporary Cognitive Science Professor Chaba Pléh, Professor of Psychology at Budapest University of Technology and Economics and visiting Professor at Indiana University, USA.
1130
Coffee
1145 -
1245
Thematic group discussions
12.45
13.00
Interim progress report led by Mike Sharples (Learning Sciences)/Jan Derry (Philosophy)
1300 -
1345
Lunch
1345 -
1445

Thematic discussions continued

1445 -
1515
Plenary
1515Tea
1530 -
1630
Kaleidoscope Philosophy of Technology-Enhanced Learning SIG planning meeting

Philosophy of Technology-Enhanced Learning Symposium:
Notes for the Thematic Group Discussions

  1. The aims of the Symposium

    • To explore how specific approaches in philosophy relate to the question of representation in the design, development and application of new technologies
    • To consider how these approaches demand a re-thinking of representation
    • To attempt to encapsulate and map approaches to the question of representation and mediated mind in technology-enhanced learning


  2. Structure of the thematic group discussions

    Each group has a Chair and we suggest appointing a Rapporteur who will take notes that will be coordinated later and shared amongst all the seminar participants.
    The groups will meet three times: At the start of the second day prior to the second keynote, after the keynote followed by an interim progress feedback (reporting on themes emerging in group discussions) and finally after lunch followed by a Plenary.
    (It is intended that the SIG web site will provide background support for the discussion and all participants are encouraged to post their own work or other relevant papers).


  3. Suggestions for discussion points

    We suggest the following general questions to initially structure each thematic group discussion:
    • What are the important issues that have been raised during the presentations and follow-on discussions yesterday that you would like to discuss further in thematic group sessions?
    • What other related issues and/or work are there that have not yet been discussed and in what ways can it be brought into the discussion?
    • In what way can we constructively map the territory in which questions of representation and mediated mind can be considered and in what way can you contribute to this process through the Philosophy of Technology-enhanced learning special interest group.


Attendees

Csaba PlehCenter of Cognitive Science,
Budapest University of Technology and Economics
& Indiana University, USA.
John Preston Department of Philosophy, University of Reading
Bruno BachimontUniversité de Technologie de Compiègne - France
Mike SharplesCentre for Educational Technology and Distance Learning,
University of Birmingham
Russell BealeSchool of Computer Science,
University of Birmingham
Leif Chr. Lahn Institute for Educational Research,
University of Oslo, Norway
Zsuzsanna Kondor Institute for Philosophical Research,
Hungarian Academy of Sciences
Vera Bekes Institute for Philosophical Research,
Hungarian Academy of Sciences
Viktor Bedo Institute for Philosophical Research,
Hungarian Academy of Sciences
Kristof NyiriInstitute for Philosophical Research,
Hungarian Academy of Sciences
Rupert WegerifSchool of Education, University of Southampton
Annamaria CarusiSchool of Education, University of Southampton
Daisy MwanzaComputing Research Centre, Open University
& IET User Lab, Institute of Educational Technology
Olga FragouEducational Technology Lab, School of Philosophy, Faculty of Pedagogy, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Charles CrookLearning Sciences Research Institute,
University of Nottingham
Daniela CerquiDepartment of Cybernetics, University of Reading
& Institute of Anthropology and Sociology,
Faculty of Social and Political Sciences,
University of Lausanne, Switzerland
Anne Light Queen Mary College, University of London
Andrew Brown Institute of Education, University of London
Jerry Hewitt Institute of Education, University of London
Sylvia WeirAssociate Fellow, London Knowledge Lab
Jan DerryLondon Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education,
University of London
Donald PetersonLondon Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education,
University of London
Arthur Bakker London Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education,
University of London
David GuileLondon Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education,
University of London
Martin OliverLondon Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education,
University of London
Sara PriceLondon Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education,
University of London
Tim NeumannLondon Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education,
University of London
Kevin WalkerLondon Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education,
University of London
Caroline PelletierLondon Knowledge Lab, Institute of Education,
University of London